• Payment confirmed by our team

Guide

Cuban Montecristo No. 2 vs No. 4: Size, Time, Which to Pick

By Vitola House Editorial Team · 6 min read

The Cuban Montecristo No. 2 is a 156 mm (6.1 in) pyramid of 52 ring gauge, about an hour by Habanos' timing; the No. 4 is a 129 mm (5.1 in) petit corona of 42 ring, about 30 minutes. Both rate medium to full, so pick by time: No. 4 for half an hour, No. 2 for an hour.

Cuban Montecristo No. 2 and No. 4 side by side, from the Habanos vitolario and formats pages
AspectMontecristo No. 2Montecristo No. 4
Factory vitolaPirámide (popular name Torpedo)Mareva (popular name Petit Corona)
Length156 mm (6.1 in)129 mm (5.1 in)
Ring gauge52 (20.6 mm)42 (16.7 mm)
ShapeFigurado, tapered headStraight-sided parejo
Smoking time (Habanos, indicative)About 1 hourAbout 30 minutes
Strength (Habanos)Medium to fullMedium to full

How long does each cigar take to smoke?

Allow about an hour for the No. 2 and about 30 minutes for the No. 4, going by the indicative times on the Habanos formats page. That is double the time for 27 mm (1.1 in) of extra length and a ring 10 points wider. Pace and cut move the figure, and for experienced smokers Habanos names the time available as the best guide, so choose the vitola you can finish.

Does strength separate the Montecristo No. 2 and No. 4?

Not on Habanos' ratings: its vitolario lists every numbered Montecristo, No. 1 to No. 5, as medium to full, so strength does not separate these two. Format never fixes strength anyway: Habanos rates the same 129 mm, 42-ring size mild under Rafael González and full under Bolívar. What differs here is size, and Habanos adds that flavour is judged only by smoking.

Does the pyramid shape change how the No. 2 smokes?

It may. Habanos classes the Pirámide as a figurado. It says a thick Habano burns slowly and gives off more smoke, while a thin one burns quicker and gathers its flavour on the tongue. Because the No. 2 tapers, its 52 ring (20.6 mm) describes the widest part, toward the foot, while the head narrows, so it sits between the two cases. That is inference from the shape, not a tasting note. The shape itself is explained in torpedo and belicoso.

Where do the No. 1, No. 3 and No. 5 fit in the line?

The No. 1, No. 3 and No. 5 are straight-sided cigars that bracket the No. 4 in length, from 102 mm to 165 mm. Habanos dates Montecristo to 1935, when it started with only five vitolas, numbered 1 to 5; of those, only the No. 2 is a pyramid.

The five numbered Cuban Montecristo vitolas, from the Habanos vitolario and formats page
CigarFactory vitolaLengthRing gaugeSmoking time (Habanos)
No. 1Cervantes165 mm (6.5 in)42 (16.7 mm)Not listed
No. 2Pirámide156 mm (6.1 in)52 (20.6 mm)About 1 hour
No. 3Corona142 mm (5.6 in)42 (16.7 mm)Over half an hour
No. 4Mareva129 mm (5.1 in)42 (16.7 mm)About 30 minutes
No. 5Perla102 mm (4.0 in)40 (15.9 mm)About 20 minutes

The No. 3 adds 13 mm (0.5 in) to the No. 4 on the same ring, so it suits a smoker who likes the No. 4's slim body but wants more time. The No. 5 is shorter and thinner.

Is every Montecristo No. 2 or No. 4 a Cuban cigar?

No. A separate brand made in the Dominican Republic also sells cigars under the Montecristo name, so a No. 2 or No. 4 from another source may not be Cuban. The Cuban one is the Habanos S.A. brand founded in Havana. Its boxes carry the Habanos warranty seal; the 2009 design has a hologram beside the coat of arms and a barcode personalised for each box, and the box base is hot-stamped Hecho en Cuba. Check the barcode on the Habanos verification page; a match is one check on the box, not proof of what is inside. What the warranty seal shows is covered at Vitola Room.

Which should you buy first, the No. 2 or the No. 4?

For a first Montecristo, pick the No. 4. Habanos advises newcomers to try a reference vitola found in several brands and calls the Mareva as close to a standard size as a Habano gets, and the No. 4 needs half the time of the No. 2. Habanos also advises beginning with a milder-rated brand, and Montecristo is medium to full, so a beginner may prefer another brand's Mareva. Our decision rules:

  • Pick the No. 4 if you have about 30 minutes, want a slim cigar, or want a Mareva to compare across brands.
  • Pick the No. 2 if you can give it an hour, like a tapered head, and have already smoked medium-to-full cigars.
  • Pick the No. 3 if the No. 4's ring suits you but you want more time.

What mistakes do buyers make comparing the two?

  • Reading the number as a size. The same No. 4 label sits on a 129 mm Mareva at Montecristo and on the Partagás Serie D No. 4, a 124 mm Robusto.
  • Expecting a strength gap, when Habanos lists both as medium to full.
  • Reading 52 as the width of the whole No. 2, when it is the widest part and the head tapers.
  • Assuming a shared name means a Cuban box.
  • Choosing the No. 2 for a short window; either allow the hour or take the No. 4.

Frequently asked questions

How much is a Montecristo No. 2 or No. 4?

Each product page shows the current box price in its price table: the Montecristo No. 2 and the Montecristo No. 4. Pack size and vitola both move the figure, so compare listings of the same pack before judging one cigar against the other.

What size is a Montecristo No. 4?

The Montecristo No. 4 measures 129 mm by 42 ring (5.1 in by 16.7 mm) and is the Mareva format, known as a petit corona. A number is only a maker's label, never a standard: Partagás Serie D No. 4 runs 124 mm on a 50 ring (4.9 in by 19.8 mm). Compare millimetres and ring gauge instead.

Is the Montecristo No. 2 a good cigar?

That depends on the hour you have, and this site publishes no scores. The No. 2 is a regular-catalogue Pirámide rated medium to full that Habanos times at about an hour. It suits a smoker who wants a tapered, unhurried cigar, and Habanos says only smoking it shows the flavour.

Is the Montecristo No. 4 a good cigar?

It fits a short window: a slim body and about 30 minutes. It is a regular-catalogue Mareva rated medium to full, and Habanos describes the No. 4 as its best-selling Habano worldwide, a company claim rather than an audited figure. It is not a rating, and it does not tell you how the cigar tastes.

Is the Montecristo No. 2 a Cuban cigar?

Yes when it is the Habanos S.A. Montecristo, and no when it is the separate Dominican-made brand that shares the name. Check the maker named on the box: a Cuban box carries the Habanos seal and a Hecho en Cuba stamp on its base, and its barcode can be checked on the Habanos verification page.

How do you cut a Montecristo No. 2?

Habanos recommends cutting a figurado 3 mm in from the edge. It advises against V-cutters, which risk breaking the cap, and against piercing the cap with a match or toothpick. For a straight-sided cigar such as the No. 4, cut right above the seam where the cap meets the wrapper.

What is the difference between the Montecristo No. 2 and No. 3?

The No. 2 is a 156 mm (6.1 in) Pirámide on a 52 ring; the No. 3 is a 142 mm (5.6 in) Corona on a 42 ring. So the No. 2 is 14 mm (0.6 in) longer, 10 ring points wider and tapered. Habanos rates both medium to full.

Cigars in this guide

The cigars named in the guide, with their product pages.

Montecristo
All guides