• Payment confirmed by our team

Guide

Cuban Montecristo vs Romeo y Julieta: Nearest Sizes and How to Choose

By Vitola House Editorial Team · 8 min read

Choosing between Cuban Montecristo and Cuban Romeo y Julieta comes down to one Habanos S.A. strength step: classic Montecristo is rated medium to full, whereas core Romeo y Julieta is rated medium. Pick the Montecristo No. 4 or No. 2 for a medium-to-full rating, and pick the Romeo y Julieta Short Churchills or No. 2 for a medium rating.

How do Cuban Montecristo and Romeo y Julieta compare at the nearest sizes?

The pairs below are the nearest catalogue formats rather than identical ones: only the first pair shares length and ring gauge, so check the dimensions before reading the strength step as the only difference.

Cuban Montecristo and Romeo y Julieta paired by nearest catalogue format (Habanos S.A. specifications)
Format pairCuban MontecristoRating, size and factory vitolaCuban Romeo y JulietaRating, size and factory vitola
Petit Corona sizeMontecristo No. 4Medium to full · 129 mm (5.1 in) × ring 42 (16.7 mm) · MarevasRomeo y Julieta No. 2Medium · 129 mm (5.1 in) × ring 42 (16.7 mm) · Petit Coronas
Compact wide ringMontecristo Petit EdmundoMedium to full · 110 mm (4.3 in) × ring 52 (20.6 mm) · Petit EdmundoRomeo y Julieta Petit ChurchillsMedium · 102 mm (4.0 in) × ring 50 (19.8 mm) · Petit Robustos
Mid-length wide ringMontecristo EdmundoMedium to full · 135 mm (5.3 in) × ring 52 (20.6 mm) · EdmundoRomeo y Julieta Short ChurchillsMedium · 124 mm (4.9 in) × ring 50 (19.8 mm) · Robustos
Flagship pairMontecristo No. 2Medium to full · 156 mm (6.1 in) × ring 52 (20.6 mm) · PirámidesRomeo y Julieta ChurchillsMedium · 178 mm (7.0 in) × ring 47 (18.7 mm) · Julieta No. 2

Every length, ring gauge, factory vitola and strength classification above comes directly from Habanos S.A.'s vitolario, which lists the Romeo No. 2 in tubes only. Box prices live in the price table on each cigar's product page and are not quoted here.

What is the real difference between the two Cuban houses?

Habanos S.A. rates the core Montecristo range medium to full and the core Romeo y Julieta range medium, and the houses differ in shape as well: Montecristo includes the tapered Pirámides, while Romeo y Julieta is the classic medium-flavour brand with one of the widest vitola ranges at Habanos S.A.

The Romeo y Julieta name dates to 1875. Montecristo arrived sixty years later, in 1935 at the H. Upmann factory in Havana, named after the Alexandre Dumas novel that the factory's reader used to read, and it began with five numbered vitolas, No. 1 through No. 5. For the archival history of the younger house, read the Montecristo brand history on Vitola Room. Habanos S.A. also rates the Montecristo sub-lines separately: Open is medium, Edmundo is medium to full and Línea 1935 is full, while the Romeo y Julieta Línea de Oro is rated medium to full. Habanos S.A. warns that strength varies between the vitolas of one brand, so confirm the rating of the exact cigar you pick. Outside Cuba you will also find brands that share these names; they are separate products and cannot be bought as equivalents of the Cuban cigars compared here. Each range is listed on the Montecristo and Romeo y Julieta brand pages.

Montecristo No. 4 vs Romeo y Julieta No. 2: which should you buy?

Buy the Montecristo No. 4 if you want a medium-to-full rating in the Petit Corona size, and buy the Romeo y Julieta No. 2 if you want a medium rating in a tube, since the Habanos vitolario lists the Romeo No. 2 in tubes.

This is the closest match in the table: both measure 129 mm (5.1 in) by 42 ring gauge (16.7 mm), and Habanos S.A. times that size at about 30 minutes. Habanos S.A. presents the Montecristo No. 4 as the best-selling Habano worldwide. If you would rather skip the tube, the vitolario also lists the untubed Romeo y Julieta Petit Coronas, rated medium. The labels are worth reading closely: Habanos lists the factory vitola Marevas for the No. 4 and Petit Coronas for the Romeo No. 2, while the untubed Petit Coronas is the other way round, a Marevas. Same dimensions, different names. To see how the two kinds of name relate, read vitola de galera vs vitola de salida.

Edmundo vs Short Churchills: which wide-ring cigar fits better?

Pick the Romeo y Julieta Short Churchills for a medium-rated robusto, a format Habanos S.A. times at 30 to 40 minutes, or pick the Montecristo Edmundo when you want extra length and a medium-to-full rating at about 50 minutes.

The Edmundo debuted in 2004 and was followed by the shorter Petit Edmundo in 2007. The Short Churchills arrived in 2006, followed by the 55 ring Wide Churchills in 2010 and the Petit Churchills in 2012. The Edmundo is 11 mm longer and 2 ring-gauge points wider than the Short Churchills (135 mm × 52 ring, 20.6 mm, against 124 mm × 50 ring, 19.8 mm), and Habanos S.A. associates the wider ring with a slower burn and more smoke. To hold the format constant, the Montecristo Open Master shares the Short Churchills' Robustos vitola and its medium rating, so on paper the only variable left is the house.

Montecristo No. 2 vs Romeo y Julieta Churchills: which flagship should you buy?

Choose the Montecristo No. 2 if you want a tapered 52 ring torpedo, about an hour according to Habanos S.A., and choose the Romeo y Julieta Churchills if you want a long, slimmer, straight-sided cigar rated medium that Habanos S.A. puts at more than an hour.

Here the geometry diverges. The Montecristo No. 2 is a Pirámides (156 mm, 6.1 in, by 52 ring, 20.6 mm), and Habanos S.A. advises cutting a figurado about 3 mm from the tip. The Romeo y Julieta Churchills is a straight-sided Julieta No. 2 (178 mm, 7.0 in, by 47 ring, 18.7 mm), which makes it 22 mm longer and 2.0 mm narrower. Habanos also lists a Montecristo Churchills Añejados on the same Julieta No. 2 factory vitola, rated medium to full, so you can hold the shape constant and change only the house. For the pyramid shape in a shorter size, the Montecristo Petit No. 2 measures 120 mm (4.7 in) by 52 ring. To compare two numbered Montecristo classics against each other, read the Montecristo No. 2 vs No. 4 guide.

How should you verify authenticity before buying either brand?

Confirm “Hecho en Cuba” on the base of the wooden box, inspect the holographic Cuban warranty seal, and check the barcode on Habanos S.A.'s official verification site.

The names alone do not establish origin, so provenance comes first. On a Cuban box the “Totalmente a Mano” mark and a factory code with a month-year ink stamp sit on the base beside the “Hecho en Cuba” stamp. From 2009 the warranty seal added a hologram and an individual barcode for every box, and you can look that code up at the Habanos S.A. authenticity portal. For storage, Habanos S.A. specifies a relative humidity of 65 to 70 % at 16 to 18 °C, and many collectors run closer to 68 to 72 %. Our shipping page covers shipping and returns, while the rules on buying or importing Cuban tobacco are set by each country, so read your local law.

Which four buying mistakes happen when comparing these two brands?

Four mistakes account for most wrong comparisons.

  • Confusing Montecristo No. 2 with Romeo y Julieta No. 2. Despite sharing “No. 2”, the Montecristo is a 156 mm × 52 ring Pirámides while the Romeo y Julieta No. 2 is a 129 mm × 42 ring Petit Coronas.
  • Relying on tasting notes for same-name brands from outside Cuba. Notes and strength charts written about those products describe something else and do not apply to the Cuban cigars compared in this guide.
  • Ignoring sub-line strength differences. Montecristo's Open line is rated medium and its Línea 1935 is rated full, while Romeo y Julieta's Línea de Oro steps up to medium to full.
  • Overlooking cutter size for the widest cigar. The Wide Churchills is a 55 ring (21.8 mm) cigar, wider than any cigar in the table above, so confirm that your cutter opens that far before you order it.

These are tobacco products for adults of legal smoking age only.

Frequently asked questions

Is Cuban Montecristo stronger than Cuban Romeo y Julieta?

Yes, across their core regular-production ranges. Habanos S.A. classifies classic Montecristo (including No. 2, No. 4 and Edmundo) as medium to full, whereas core Romeo y Julieta (including Churchills, Short Churchills and No. 2) is classified as medium. Sub-lines such as Montecristo Open (medium) and Romeo y Julieta Línea de Oro (medium to full) are exceptions.

Which brand is better for someone new to Cuban cigars?

Core Romeo y Julieta is the lower-rated entry point, because Habanos S.A. rates its main vitolas medium rather than medium to full. Habanos S.A. also advises newcomers to start with a reference vitola found in several brands, and the Romeo y Julieta No. 2 and Montecristo No. 4 both offer one at 129 mm by 42 ring.

Why are Montecristo No. 2 and Romeo y Julieta No. 2 completely different sizes?

Because cigar numbers are brand-specific commercial names, not universal size codes. Montecristo No. 2 is a 156 mm (6.1 in) by 52 ring Pirámides torpedo, while Romeo y Julieta No. 2 is a 129 mm (5.1 in) by 42 ring Petit Coronas. Always check length, ring gauge and factory vitola before ordering.

Are Cuban Montecristo and Romeo y Julieta the same as cigars with those names sold elsewhere?

No, treat them as different products. Brands with the same names also exist outside Cuba and cannot be bought as equivalents of the Cuban cigars compared here. Check the “Hecho en Cuba” stamp on the box base and the Habanos warranty seal, then confirm the seal's barcode on the official verification page.

How is the box price of each cigar shown?

Every product page has a price table with the current box price, which depends on the vitola, the number of cigars in the box and the packaging. Open the table for each cigar you are weighing and set it beside the dimensions and Habanos ratings given above, since the two houses do not always match in size.

Sources

  1. Habanos S.A., Official Vitolario: the vitolas of both houses with their sizes and strength classifications.
  2. Habanos S.A., Montecristo brand page: 1935 founding, No. 4 sales standing, Edmundo (2004) and Petit Edmundo (2007).
  3. Habanos S.A., Romeo y Julieta brand page: when the name appeared (1875) and when its Churchill formats were launched.
  4. Habanos S.A., Principales formatos: approximate smoking times by factory vitola.
  5. Habanos S.A., Authenticity verification and storage guide.

Updated November 2026.

Cigars in this guide

The cigars named in the guide, with their product pages.

Montecristo
All guides